Sunday Notes: A Corridor of Fame Poll Defined

This month I had the glory of filling out a Corridor of Fame poll for the third time, and as soon as once more I put checkmarks subsequent to 10 names. As I wrote in final yr’s explanatory column, I’m each “a Huge-Corridor man” and keen (albeit begrudgingly) to look previous steroid implications. As I see it, the story of baseball on this period can’t be instructed with out Alex Rodriguez and Manny Ramirez, every of whom received my vote.

That the story might fairly be instructed with out among the names I’ve chosen to checkmark is, admittedly, a legitimate argument in opposition to exercising the complete allotment. That is one thing I’ve chewed on, however in the end determined isn’t the best way I need to strategy my poll. The Corridor features a plethora of gamers who weren’t the most effective of the most effective — Bruce Sutter was no Warren Spahn; Rick Ferrell no Johnny Bench — and whereas “X is in, so ought to Y” is imperfect logic, so too is “Y wasn’t a Bench or a Spahn, so isn’t worthy.” Figuring out who deserves a plaque in Cooperstown is something however an actual science.

My 2023 choices — asterisks indicating that I voted for the participant final yr — are Bobby Abreu*, Carlos Beltrán, Todd Helton*, Andruw Jones*, Jeff Kent, Manny Ramirez*, Alex Rodriguez*, Scott Rolen*, Gary Sheffield, and Billy Wagner*.

Beltrán is new to the poll. Extra on him in a second.

Kent was the participant I most wished I might have discovered room for on final yr’s stacked poll, which included the no-longer-eligible Barry Bonds, and Roger Clemens, and the now-enshrined David Ortiz — all of whom received my vote. Utilizing one of many now-open slots for Kent was a straightforward selection. Together with having 337 residence runs — probably the most ever for a second baseman — the notoriously-prickly infielder had a 123 wRC+ which ranks tenth-highest at his place during the last century (minimal 5,000 plate appearances). Furthermore, in his 10-year prime he had a 133 wRC+ to associate with 5 All-Star berths and an MVP award.

One other of Kent’s numbers that stands out is his 984 extra-base hits; solely 42 gamers, at any place, have extra. Sheffield is amongst them. The temperamental slugger acquired a checkmark on my 2021 poll, solely to fall off final yr (as did final-year-eligible Sammy Sosa) to make room for first-year-eligibles Ortiz and A-Rod. Sheffield’s bona fides, which embody 509 residence runs and a 141 wRC+, are well-known. As was the case with Kent, defensive limitations had been outweighed by a prolific bat.

Whereas Kent and Sheffield had been comparatively straightforward selections — ditto my seven holdovers — Beltrán wasn’t. The Astros’ dishonest scandal left a bitter style that also lingers, and the 57.8 WAR outfielder’s involvement has already value him a managerial job. Ought to it additionally value him a plaque in Cooperstown? Addressing that conundrum, my esteemed colleague Jay Jaffe wrote earlier this month that “it might be a mistake to ship Beltrán’s case into oblivion.” With that in thoughts, and after little bit of contemplation — this with the data that dishonest, together with signal stealing, has been a part of the sport since its inception — I took a deep breath and checked Beltrán’s identify.

Had I made a decision in any other case, my tenth and remaining vote would have gone to Andy Pettitte. The veteran of 18 big-league seasons is arguably a borderline candidate at greatest, however together with Mark Buehrle — the southpaws are statistically-similar in a number of classes — he deserves an extended look. Pettitte (68.2) amassed extra profession WAR than Tom Glavine (66.7), Juan Marichal (61.2) and Don Drysdale (59.3). Does that, together with 256 wins and a prolonged post-season resume, make him Corridor-worthy? Once more, figuring out who deserves a plaque in Cooperstown is something however an actual science.

The seven holdover candidates I voted for, in addition to my not placing a checkmark subsequent to Francisco Rodríguez’s identify, had been addressed when Jay Jaffe, Travis Sawchik, and I mentioned our 2023 ballots in Friday’s episode of FanGraphs Audio.



Matt Holliday went 3 for 11 in opposition to Jon Garland.

Jamey Carroll went 2 for 4 Neftalí Feliz.

Bill North went 2 for five in opposition to Dick Pole.

Rob Deer went 1 for 8 in opposition to Goose Gossage.

David DeJesus went 1 for six in opposition to Chris Carpenter.


Matt Quatraro was employed lower than two months in the past, so he’s nonetheless studying concerning the gamers he’ll be managing in Kansas Metropolis. The method takes time, and it gained’t be till spring coaching is effectively underway that he has a agency grasp of their personalities and, to a lesser extent, the talent units they possess. Through the Winter Conferences, I requested the previous Tampa Bay Rays bench coach for an instance of one thing he’s already realized.

“The very first thing that involves thoughts is how extremely everybody thinks of Maikel Garcia as a defender,” stated Quatraro, naming the Royals’ top-rated prospect. “There’s a variety of sentiment within the group about how good he’s, and might be, as an infielder. Whereas I used to be conversant in him, that’s one thing I didn’t actually know.”

Presently slashing .320/.436/.492 with the Venezuelan Winter League’s Tiburones de La Guaira, Garcia made his big-league debut this yr, showing in 9 video games. The 22-year-old shortstop is No. 66 on our Top 100, with a 50 FV.


A quiz:

Shoeless Joe Jackson, who’s ineligible, has the very best profession batting common (.356) amongst modern-era gamers not within the Corridor of Fame. Which eligible, modern-era non-Corridor of Famer has the very best batting common (minimal 5,000 plate appearances)?

The reply might be discovered under.



Rylee Pay can be becoming a member of the Double-A Portland Sea Canines as a Broadcast and Media Relations Assistant subsequent season. A current UNLV graduate who has known as video games within the Cape Cod League, Pay will share a sales space with Emma Tiedemann.

Wayne Randazzo will reportedly be the brand new TV voice of the Los Angeles Angeles. The 38-year-old Randazzo, who has been with the New York Mets since 2019, is slated to work alongside analyst Mark Gubicza.

Tom Browning, who pitched for the Cincinnati Reds from 1984-1994, and for the Kansas Metropolis Royals in 1995, died earlier this week at age 62. The southpaw, who together with Ralph Terry is considered one of simply two pitchers to complete his profession with precisely 1,000 strikeouts, tossed an ideal recreation in opposition to the Los Angeles Dodgers in 1988.

Denny Doyle, a second baseman who performed for 3 groups — the Philadelphia Phillies, California Angels, and Boston Pink Sox — from 1970-1977, died this week at age 78. The Glasgow, Kentucky native had the lone hit in one-hitters thrown by Nolan Ryan (1970), Gary Nolan (1971), and Steve Arlin (1972).


The reply to the quiz is Riggs Stephenson, who had a .336 batting common over 5,136 plate appearances from 1921-1934. The left-handed-hitting outfielder batted .336 in 9 seasons with the Cubs, and .337 in 5 seasons with Cleveland.


Final Sunday’s column led with Masataka Yoshida opining on the most effective pitchers in Japan, and adopted with Gus Quattlebaum addressing the potential for Fukuoka SoftBank Hawks nearer Liván Moinelo coming to MLB. Left on the reducing room flooring from my dialog with Quattlebaum had been his ideas on one other elite NPB reliever. In 9 seasons with the Tohoku Rakuten Golden Eagles, Yuki Matsui has 197 saves to go along with 788 strikeouts, and simply 398 hits allowed, in 602-and-third innings.

“We noticed him in opposition to [Yoshida] — I imagine it was in Sendai, at Rakuten’s discipline— and he’s somebody who pops for the pitch knowledge,” Boston’s VP of Scouting stated of the 27-year-old southpaw. “That’s together with his fastball, the way it performs. He’s not an enormous man, and he gained’t wow you with velocity, however he’s undoubtedly fascinating.”

Matsui, who’s listed at 174cm/ 74kg [5-foot-8, 163 pounds], is coming off of a season the place he logged 32 saves and a 1.92 ERA, with 83 strikeouts and 21 hits allowed in 51-and-two-thirds innings. Quattlebaum stated that the Pink Sox haven’t adopted Matsui intently, as he hasn’t been posted by Rakuten.



The Fukuoka SoftBank Hawks have signed former Minnesota Twins and Miami Marlins jack-of-all-trades Willians Astudillo. The 31-year-old native of Barcelona, Venezuela performed each place beside shortstop in elements of 5 big-league seasons.

Jung-hoo Lee has reportedly requested to be posted after the upcoming KBO season. Extensively considered the most effective participant in Korea, the 24-year-old, left-handed-hitting outfielder slashed .349/.421/.575 with a 175 wRC+ for the Kiwoom Heroes.

Jermaine Palacios is slashing .400/.471/.633 in 138 plate appearances with Cardenales de Lara within the Venezuelan Winter League. The 26-year-old infielder/outfielder made his MLB debut with the Minnesota Twins this yr and is now within the Detroit Tigers group.

César Valdez is 6-0 with a 1.51 ERA in 53-and-two-thirds innings for Tigres del Licey within the Dominican Winter League. The 37-year-old changeup artist re-signed with the Los Angeles Angles earlier this month after spent most of final season with their Triple-A affiliate.


Circling again to the Corridor of Fame, I introduced up the non-enshrined Bob Johnson in Friday’s episode of FanGraphs Audio. An outfielder whose relatively-short MLB profession spanned the 1933-1945 seasons, “Indian Bob” is statistically near Chuck Klein, who performed from 1928-1944 and was elected to the HoF by the Veterans Committee in 1980. Here’s a snapshot of their numbers:

Johnson: 2.051 hits, 396 doubles, 288 HRs, 3,501 whole bases, 133 wRC+.
Klein: 2,076 hits, 398 doubles, 300 HRs, 3,522 whole bases, 133 wRC+.

Klein gained an MVP award, however was an All-Star simply twice. Johnson, whose high-water mark in MVP voting was a fifth-place end, was a seven-time All-Star. As for his or her WAR totals — one thing the Veterans Committee clearly wasn’t — Johnson has a transparent edge: 57.0 to 42.8 by our calculations, and 55.6 to 46.5 by B-Ref’s.

Why is Klein within the Corridor of Fame, and Johnson on the surface wanting in? In all probability, the largest cause isn’t the MVP, however reasonably batting common. Klein completed with a horny .320, whereas Johnson completed under the long-admired .300 mark at .296. May issues be totally different if the Nineteen Thirties-Nineteen Forties contemporaries had been up for election now, both by the BBWAA or an period committee? One would definitely hope so.



The Chicago-Solar Instances’s Maddie Lee took us inside the assembly that set the Cubs aside of their pursuit of Jameson Taillon.

Brew Crew Ball’s Jack Stern thinks Rowdy Tellez is positioned for a breakout season in 2023.

Pink Reporter’s Wick Terrell wrote an appreciation of Tom Browning.

Analysis exhibits that the vanity of sports activities followers is linked to their crew, and wrote about it for The Washington Publish.



The San Francisco Giants had 28 bunt hits this yr, probably the most within the majors. The Atlanta Braves had two bunts hits, the fewest within the majors.

Tyler Beede is ready to develop into the thirteenth participant to play for each the San Francisco Giants and NPB’s Yomiuri Giants, becoming a member of Edgardo Alfonzo, Cory Bailey, John Bowker, Keith Comstock, Felipe Crespo, Hector Cruz, Dan Gladden, Casey McGehee, Gerardo Parra, Reggie Smith , Justin Smoak, and Gary Thomasson. (per Natsuki Une, by way of @NPB_Reddit)

Mel Ott had 4 seasons with precisely 100 walks. His strikeout totals in these years had been 39, 50, 50, and 68. He homered 38 occasions in his 39-strikeout season.

Johnny Frederick had 200 profession doubles in a profession that spanned the 1929-1934 seasons. The Brooklyn Robins/Dodgers outfielder’s yearly totals had been a rookie-record 52 doubles, adopted by seasons with 44, 34, 28, 22, and 20.

Detroit Tigers shortstop Eddie Lake had 127 hits and 120 walks in 1947. Chicago White Sox second baseman Don Kolloway had 135 hits and 17 walks that yr.

Gamers born on at this time’s date embody Ned Garver, who pitched for shedding groups all through most of a profession that spanned the 1948-1961 seasons. The suitable-hander from Ney, Ohio (inhabitants 258) went 129-158 regardless of a 112 ERA+. Most notable was his 1958 marketing campaign when he went 13-18 with a 146 ERA+ for the St. Louis Browns. A yr later, he went 20-12 for a Browns crew that gained solely 52 video games.

Additionally born on at this time’s date was Quincy Trouppe, who performed all however the remaining season of his profession within the Negro Leagues. The catcher/outfielder debuted in MLB in 1952 at age 39 and logged one hit in 10 at-bats with the Cleveland Indians.